Workers Behaving Badly
The Conference Board Review (02/10) Liberman, Vadim
In the wake of market crashes and company frauds, many organizations have called for a zero-tolerance policy on unethical workplace behavior. There is always a line, however, somewhere between the unethical actions of taking an office pencil and that of committing Enron-sized fraud. Some studies have shown that about one-third of company employees steal supplies occasionally, half of them do it regularly, and about one-fifth of them steal large amounts, meaning that nearly everyone does this at some point. Sociologists have suggested that companies may want to look the other way when workers commit small infractions, allowing them to let off some steam, rather than crack down on minor thefts that could fuel resentment and prompt a larger act of retribution. Other businesses have simply accepted the losses of stolen office supplies as a cost of doing business. Experts also acknowledge, however, that too much permission may lead to even greater infractions and losses in profit, while drawing the line between small problems and significant ones is usually difficult, if not impossible. To rein in smaller unethical actions, managers and executives may want to address specific problems that they have witnessed, such as a suspicious expense accounts. This carries additional problems, says the article’s author, Vadim Liberman, as a company may risk an even larger loss if their best workers are reprimanded, so “playing dumb to his self-appointed ‘perks’ might be not only your smartest move but also your most ethical if it means making enough money to keep other workers employed.” At the same time, other employees may resent what they see as preferential treatments, so companies must engage in a cost-benefit analysis even when it comes to office ethics. Business-ethics consultant Lauren Bloom pointed out, “Unless you’re talking about illegal things, ethics are always to some degree a bit of a judgment call.” Ultimately, companies may not want to try drawing a line at all, but instead make sure their employees know what is generally expected, and are aware of the organization’s overall values.


Recent Comments